Mystery Stocking

Mystery Stockings contain Donuts or a Reindeer and cost 50 Santa Coins. There was an update on January 2, 2013 installing the Mystery Stockings and the dialogue following into the game, but they didn't appear until January 3, 2013. The stockings were introduced to allow the players to convert their excess Santa Coins to permanent items, which was opposed to the experience after the Halloween content update, when the surplus of Treats just vanished.

Character Dialogue
Homer Icon "I can't wait till the holidays are over and I can eat all our leftover Santa coins...just like I did with the Halloween candy."
Lisa Icon "But not all those coins are made of chocolate. Some of them are made of coin."
Homer Icon "Doesn't matter. I'm still going to eat them."
Lisa Icon "How about if instead we use them to buy Mystery Stockings, which contain all sorts of goodies."
Homer Icon "And then I can eat those? Lisa, you're a genius!"
Use surplus Santa Coins to buy Mystery Stockings before the Holiday Event ends on January 10th.
— In Game Message
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.