Talk:Moonshine Shack/@comment-25486382-20151229233422/@comment-26143371-20151229234217

Should have triggered then. Two things I can think of:
 * Is Cletus idle? He triggers the quest.
 * Did you try switching to Krustyland and back? That sometimes helps when a quest doesn't trigger.

And if it's only for Maggie and not the Mistletoe you'll miss out, there is another questline during Act 3 which will reward her and which is completely independent from this one. Act 3 will mainly focus on Maggie, so everybody needs a chance to get her, even if they didn't play the first two acts.