Talk:Winter 2015 Event/@comment-70.209.106.60-20151213062657/@comment-26818419-20151220023648

You only get more if the other person decides to be Nice and you go Naughty, if you both go Naughty there's little benefit.

Personally, I've only tapped Naughty once (someone dropped five naughty presents in my town and I didn't give them satifaction on the 5th one). I prefer Nice because it's the most balanced of the options and it's not greedy.