Board Thread:Tapped Out Help/@comment-4477853-20160206092641/@comment-26143371-20160206164508

Yeah, it's definitively a bug and it's practically the same thing they forget regularly: Only the buildings in the town count, not the ones in the inventory.

For Paradise Found this means in order to get Pt. X, you will need a Private Island at Level X in you town and you mustn't have a Private Island of a higher Level (again in your town).

Personally I only have one island and it is on level two. So I got Pt. 2 of the questline. I've stored it and got Pt. 1, took it back out and completed Pt. 1.

@Auctorius I suppose you had all of your islands in the inventory? If that's the case then you're stuck with the quest in your taskbook and there's nothing you can do except waiting for an update that fixes the issue.

@Locoquito Just make sure you don't store all of them simultaneously, otherwise you will be stuck with an uncompletable task as well.